Scanning Insurance Cards
by Bob Glorioso, MD
June 2005
Patient Records 8.1 now supports importing and displaying images of insurance cards through the Patient Screen. There is no longer a need to Plink the images. Multiple card images can be saved if the patient has more than one insurer or if the patient’s insurance changes. The MedicScan scanner/software allows rapid scanning of cards.
MedicScan ($349, Scanshell scanner and MedicScan software) http://www.medicscan.com/MedicScan.aspx. This is the better option since it scans both sides of the card into one file and only requires inserting the card into the scanner, flipping it and re-inserting it, then importing through Practice Partner. MedicScan Pro and MedicScan OCR are more expensive and do not improve the workflow.
Or
Scanshell 800N ($199 scanner only) http://www.medicscan.com/800N.aspx
plus Fujitsu Scandall 21 (free software download). http://www.fcpa.com/support/scanners/drivers_downloads.html
Each side of the card is scanned as a separate file and requires 3 clicks to start each scan. Each file is imported separately through Practice Partner, which is more time-consuming.
i. Under Driver’s Licenses tab, leave default settings
ii. Change path to C:\ (This is the default path for Practice Partner to import the file. This saves a lot of time navigating. These files are deleted at import)
iii. Click OK
(near bottom of web page)
*How settings affect quality and file size
Practice Partner only supports jpeg, bmp and gif files in the Patient screen images. Jpegs give good quality at a fairly small size. Bmps are too large, and most scanner software won’t scan to gifs. Here are results of scanning a plastic PPO Blue card to jpeg using ScandAll 21 with various settings:
|
Resolution (dpi) |
Color depth |
File size (KB) |
Quality |
Source |
|
75 |
Grey |
5.9 |
Poor |
Front of card |
|
75 |
Black |
9.16 |
Poor |
Front of card |
|
75 |
Color |
8.84 |
Poor |
Front of card |
|
100 |
Grey |
8.92 |
Fair |
Front of card |
|
100 |
Black |
13.3 |
Fair |
Front of card |
|
100 |
Color |
13.9 |
Fair |
Front of card |
|
150 |
Grey |
18.7 |
Good |
Front of card |
|
150 |
Black |
24.9 |
Fair |
Front of card |
|
150 |
Color |
26.7 |
Good |
Front of card |
|
150 |
Grey |
28.3 |
Good |
Back |
|
150 |
Black |
39.0 |
Good |
Back |
|
150 |
Color |
37.4 |
Good |
Back |
Poor: Some key names/numbers not legible
Fair: All key names/numbers legible, some writing difficult to read
Good: All key names/numbers and all writing legible
Scanning the same card using MedicScan Software:
|
Resolution (dpi) |
Color depth |
File size (KB) |
Quality |
Source |
|
100 |
Grey |
32 |
Fair/Good |
Front/back |
|
150 |
Grey |
64 |
Good |
Front/back |
Quality of images and how large a file size that you will tolerate is an individual decision. Both 100 and 150 dpi greyscale are reasonable choices. The total storage requirement of scanning cards is small with either choice:
|
Software |
Resolution (dpi) |
Color depth |
File size (KB) |
5000 cards |
|
Scandall 21 |
100 |
Grey |
20 |
100MB |
|
Scandall 21 |
150 |
Grey |
47 |
235MB |
|
MedicScan |
100 |
Grey |
32 |
160MB |
|
MedicScan |
150 |
Grey |
64 |
320MB |